Episode 8 Season 2 59:33

Ethics & Duty of Care in the Age of AI Coaching: “I Didn’t Know” Is No Longer a Defence | with Dr. Benita Mayhead

Dr. Benita Mayhead is a coach, coach supervisor, EMCC UK board member, and author of Duty of Care in Coaching. Her doctoral research asked practitioners where their ethics come from, and not one of them said coach training. Now AI has arrived on top of that foundation, and she keeps asking one question: in whose service? In this conversation with Rebecca Rutschmann, she unpacks what separates compliance, ethics, and duty of care, and why "I didn't know" is no longer a defence. Benita doesn't use AI with her own clients, and she's not a naysayer either. She argues the debate has moved from "should we?" to "how?", and that the answer has to be one a coach can explain to their client. Together they look at who holds responsibility when the platform, the employer, the coach, and the client each hold a piece. Her closing definition: if it's not for the client, it's not ethical AI usage. What you'll take away: Why no practitioner in Benita's research traced their ethics to coach training, and what that means for AI The difference between compliance, ethics, and duty of care, and why foreseeable harm is the test Why "I didn't know" is not a shield, and what coaches are responsible for finding out Why ethically mature coaches may feel more discomfort, not less What coach educators and accrediting bodies owe the next generation of coaches The one question to ask before every AI decision: in whose service? Resources and mentions: Book: Duty of Care in Coaching: A Comprehensive Approach to Navigating the Complexities of Contemporary Practice (Routledge) Website: benitamayhead.com (free one-page-per-chapter book snapshot and thesis snapshot) Doctoral thesis: Duty of care in coaching: from ethical frameworks to the development of the coach, Oxford Brookes University, 2022  Association for Coaching Coaching Voices podcast: In Whose Service? Duty of Care in an AI-Augmented Coaching World Website: The Edge of Human & AI

Ethics & Duty of Care in the Age of AI Coaching: “I Didn’t Know” Is No Longer a Defence | with Dr. Benita Mayhead – Episode Artwork
Share this episode:

Episode Description

Dr. Benita Mayhead is a coach, coach supervisor, EMCC UK board member, and author of Duty of Care in Coaching. Her doctoral research asked practitioners where their ethics come from, and not one of them said coach training. Now AI has arrived on top of that foundation, and she keeps asking one question: in whose service?

In this conversation with Rebecca Rutschmann, she unpacks what separates compliance, ethics, and duty of care, and why "I didn't know" is no longer a defence. Benita doesn't use AI with her own clients, and she's not a naysayer either. She argues the debate has moved from "should we?" to "how?", and that the answer has to be one a coach can explain to their client. Together they look at who holds responsibility when the platform, the employer, the coach, and the client each hold a piece. Her closing definition: if it's not for the client, it's not ethical AI usage.

What you'll take away:

  • Why no practitioner in Benita's research traced their ethics to coach training, and what that means for AI
  • The difference between compliance, ethics, and duty of care, and why foreseeable harm is the test
  • Why "I didn't know" is not a shield, and what coaches are responsible for finding out
  • Why ethically mature coaches may feel more discomfort, not less
  • What coach educators and accrediting bodies owe the next generation of coaches
  • The one question to ask before every AI decision: in whose service?

Resources and mentions:

About the Guest

Dr. Benita Mayhead